A leader can introduce gratitude practices, talk about strengths, and encourage purpose while still humiliating people in meetings. Positive leadership requires attention to the harm people experience as well as the support they receive.
Previous work on bad interpersonal conduct
Stanford professor of management, Bob Sutton, published the bestselling book The No Asshole Rule, which made the case for addressing destructive interpersonal conduct at work. His work asks organizations to take mistreatment seriously and asks readers to examine their own behavior.
For GLI, that perspective raises a concrete concern: an organization can celebrate positive leadership while leaving employees exposed to demeaning treatment. A balanced approach gives prevention an explicit place alongside development.
What the new research examined
In Avoiding the worst leaders is more important than getting the best, Hallgeir Sjåstad, Jareef Martuza, and Jay J. Van Bavel report two observational studies and five experiments. The experimental samples totaled 51,433 participants and included a large study spanning 40 countries.
The observational work examined business-school statements and Glassdoor employee reviews. The experiments compared willingness to make sacrifices to avoid a very bad leader with willingness to make sacrifices to obtain a very good leader, using an average leader as the comparison. Leader descriptions varied moral character, competence, or both.
What they found
- Negative leadership experiences featured prominently in reviews. Among 422,956 reviews flagged for leadership mentions, 65.6% mentioned a leader in the negative section and 38.4% in the positive section. Reviews could mention leaders in both. Negative mentions were more strongly associated with overall company ratings than positive mentions.
- Participants placed greater weight on avoiding bad leaders. In the 40-country experiment, 48.1% were willing to forgo a hypothetical 5% salary increase to avoid a bad leader, compared with 37.7% to obtain a good leader. This is a difference of 10.4 percentage points. The overall effect was statistically significant in 31 of the 40 countries.
- The pattern also appeared with money at stake. In a separate experiment, 54.5% chose to sacrifice £1 to avoid a bad supervisor, compared with 43.3% to obtain a good supervisor for a possible follow-up task.
What a balanced reading requires
The October 2026 manuscript is a working paper posted before peer review. Its conclusions may change.
The experiments provide evidence about leadership preferences under controlled conditions. They do not establish the comparative effects of real leaders on long-term health, retention, or performance. Most choices were hypothetical; the monetary experiment strengthens the behavioral evidence but remains a brief research setting.
Glassdoor reviews are self-selected, and associations between leadership mentions and company ratings cannot establish causation.
The research also includes incompetent leaders, so its scope extends beyond interpersonal mistreatment, which is an important and interesting distinction that requires further study.
Prevent harm and develop positive leadership
This complementary perspective has roots in earlier work by GLI founder, Dr. Rasmussen. In their 2003 chapter, Striking a Vital Balance: Developing a Complementary Focus on Human Weakness and Strength Through Positive Psychological Assessment, Shane J. Lopez, C. R. Snyder, and Rasmussen argued for assessing strengths alongside weaknesses. That chapter concerned psychological assessment, but the broader principle applies to leadership too. It is important to balance examining harmful patterns and positive actions together.
A balanced view gives leaders the responsibility to stop harmful patterns and create better conditions for work.
Removing humiliation does not automatically create trust, meaningful work, strengths development, or manageable demands. Conversely, appreciation and purpose cannot be assumed to offset persistent mistreatment.
Across GLI’s six domains, prevention and development can work together: a positive climate needs credible appreciation and protection from ridicule; positive relationships need reliability and repair; positive communication needs candid feedback without humiliation. Meaning and purpose require clear connections to contribution, strengths-based leadership requires opportunities to develop capabilities, and well-being and flourishing require attention to workload, recovery, and vitality.
A practical check for leaders
- Describe conduct precisely. Ask about interruptions, public put-downs, retaliation, exclusion, and broken commitments. Avoid using a provocative label as a substitute for evidence.
- Make concerns safe to raise. Offer a route beyond the immediate supervisor, follow up on reports, and examine whether employees experience retaliation.
- Keep accountability clear. Challenging an idea, setting a standard, and addressing poor performance can be respectful. A single incident can still require the leader to take prompt action.
For your next team review: What behavior needs to stop, and what condition needs to improve? Assign responsibility and a follow-up date to each.
When your own leadership needs attention
It is easier to recognize harmful leadership in someone else. Your intentions, expertise, and commitment do not tell you everything about how people experience your behavior. Stress or pressure may help explain a reaction, but you still need to address its impact.
After a difficult meeting or conversation, reflect on specific behavior:
- How did I respond to disagreement? Did I ask questions and consider the concern, or interrupt, ridicule, dismiss, or become defensive?
- What did my authority make difficult to say? Did people have a real opportunity to challenge my decision or acknowledge a mistake without fearing consequences?
- Did I create avoidable strain? Did I change priorities without clarifying trade-offs, make commitments I did not keep, or expect availability that interferes with recovery?
- Whose perspective am I missing? Do I listen as carefully to people with less status as I do to senior colleagues? Have I asked for a concrete example of something I could do differently?
Self-reflection is a starting point. Seek feedback through channels that protect employees, including confidential feedback or a structured review facilitated by someone outside your reporting line. Do not treat silence as proof that everything is fine.
If you identify a harmful pattern, name the behavior, acknowledge its impact without asking employees to reassure you, and make a specific change. For example: “I cut you off when you raised a concern. That prevented us from examining a risk. I will make room for you to finish and ask questions before responding.” Arrange follow-up and check whether people experience improvement. Persistent or serious conduct may also require formal accountability and support beyond private reflection.
These reflection prompts are GLI educational tools, not a validated assessment or an intervention tested in the featured preprint.
Sources and attribution
Lopez, S. J., Snyder, C. R., & Rasmussen, H. N. (2003). Striking a vital balance: Developing a complementary focus on human weakness and strength through positive psychological assessment. In S. J. Lopez & C. R. Snyder (Eds.), Positive psychological assessment: A handbook of models and measures (pp. 3–20). American Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/10612-001. Publisher information.
Sjåstad, H., Martuza, J., & Van Bavel, J. J. (2026, October). Avoiding the worst leaders is more important than getting the best [Preprint]. Supplied manuscript; not peer reviewed.
Sutton, R. I. (2007). The no asshole rule: Building a civilized workplace and surviving one that isn’t. Warner Business Books. See the author’s book page for his description of the work and forthcoming anniversary edition.
This brief separates the preprint’s reported findings, Sutton’s management perspective, and GLI’s practical synthesis. The suggested practices have not been evaluated as a package in the featured study.
Research on leadership and workplace well-being, translated into practical ideas for your workplace.
Get the Friday Research Brief →